Madison Gazette

From the Square to the wider world

Dining

One Dish, Done Right: The Enduring Magic of Paul's Pel'meni

For more than two decades, a tiny counter near campus has served exactly one thing — Russian dumplings with ‘the works’ — and become the comfort food of a city's late nights.

A bowl of pelmeni dumplings with melted butter, curry powder, cilantro and sour cream
Pel'meni with “the works”: butter, curry, cilantro, chili sauce and sour cream. AI-generated illustration for Madison Gazette

There is no menu at Paul's Pel'meni, not really. There are dumplings — beef or potato, full order or half — and the only real decision is whether to get them with “the works.” Regulars will tell you there is no decision at all.

Paul Schwoerer has operated the one-item dumpling shop, with occasional interruptions, since 2003, according to Eater Chicago's guide to essential Madison restaurants. The current counter at 414 W. Gilman St., a few blocks from the Capitol, keeps the formula unchanged: Russian pel'meni, boiled, slicked with melted butter, dusted with yellow curry powder, brightened with cilantro, finished with sweet chili heat and a side of sour cream.

The economics are part of the legend. A half order runs about $7, and essentially everything on offer costs less than $10 — which is why Travel + Leisure's Madison guide sends readers there for a nightcap and why the shop has anchored student budgets for generations.

Get the full order, not the half. Get the works. And don't plan to eat just one.

The national food press keeps rediscovering it. Tasting Table recently counted Paul's among America's must-visit restaurants that specialize in a single dish, and Cheapism put it on a list of restaurants famous for one popular dish. The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel's dining writer went further, calling it her favorite Madison find “…ever,” and lamenting that Milwaukee has nothing like it.

Part of the devotion is timing. Paul's is one of a handful of Madison kitchens still open truly late — until 2 a.m. on weekends — making it the traditional final chapter of a State Street evening, the place where the night is replayed over a paper tray of dumplings.

The advice from everyone, everywhere, converges: get the full order, not the half. Get the works. And don't plan to eat just one.

Paul's Pel'meni restaurants dumplings late night Gilman Street

← Back to the front page