Dane County DA Declines to Charge Madison Officer in Fatal Shooting of Corey Ruiz
District Attorney Ismael Ozanne said Officer Kiel Baitinger-Peterson acted reasonably when he shot the 38-year-old on July 22. The family, represented by Ben Crump, is weighing a civil rights suit.
Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne announced Thursday that no criminal charges will be filed against the Madison police officer who shot and killed Corey Ruiz on July 22, concluding that Officer Kiel Baitinger-Peterson acted reasonably when Ruiz resisted arrest and produced a knife. The decision drew swift condemnation from Ruiz's family and their supporters.
Ozanne laid out his reasoning in a four-page statement released after he met privately with Ruiz's family. “I conclude it was reasonable for the officer to use deadly force when this person resisted officers, produced a knife, and was not affected by multiple attempts to use Tasers while officers attempted to take him into custody,” he wrote, adding that the officers faced no “potential criminal court liability.” No charges will be filed against the three other officers involved.
The encounter began with a 911 call reporting that a man, later identified as Ruiz, 38, had tried to break into a home and had stolen a bicycle, according to the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel's account of the decision. Four officers responded to reports of someone checking parked cars. Baitinger-Peterson, an officer with more than a decade of experience, fired three shots, striking Ruiz twice, after two Taser attempts proved ineffective.
We're destroyed. We won't accept this.
At a packed Thursday news conference at Madison's Center for Black Excellence and Culture, civil rights attorney Ben Crump, who represents the family, said he was exploring other legal avenues, including a civil rights lawsuit. “There is nothing in the videos the district attorney showed us that justifies this officer stepping back, pulling his gun, and firing three shots at point-blank range,” Crump said.
Ruiz's brother, Adam Ruiz, told reporters the prosecutor had “mistreated” the family. “We're destroyed,” he said. “We won't accept this.” Ruiz's mother, Elsa, said, “It hurts so bad,” and his 13-year-old daughter, Kah'liyah Aliomar, told the room, “Racism is still out there,” according to the Associated Press and the Journal Sentinel.
Elected officials reacted along familiar lines. State Sen. Kelda Roys, D-Madison, called the decision a “miscarriage of justice,” and Rep. Francesca Hong, who represents the neighborhood where Ruiz was shot, called it “disturbing,” the Cap Times reported. Hours before the announcement, demonstrators stood outside the Dane County Courthouse holding signs reading “Justice for Corey Ruiz.”
The case is not necessarily over. Channel 3000 reported that Madison police are opening an internal review of the shooting and that the state Department of Justice released additional video on Thursday. Under Wisconsin's John Doe statute, the investigative file and a written explanation of the decision must be forwarded to a judge, according to the city's Office of the Independent Police Monitor. The shooting also spurred the City Council to fund a police body-camera program in the 2027 budget.


