Madison Gazette

From the Square to the wider world

Madison

Family Rejects DA's Ruling as Madison Police Open Internal Review of the Corey Ruiz Shooting

*A day after Dane County's district attorney declined to file charges, the Ruiz family asked the community to be its "judge and jury," and Chief John Patterson said the department's own review — with an outside expert — is just beginning.*

Candles, flowers and ribbons left at a street-corner memorial fence at dusk
A memorial of candles and flowers has marked the intersection of Baldwin and Williamson streets since July. AI-generated illustration for Madison Gazette

A day after Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne declined to charge the Madison officer who fatally shot Corey Ruiz in July, the Ruiz family said it does not accept the decision, while Madison police announced an internal use-of-force review that will include an independent outside evaluation.

Ozanne announced Thursday, after a four-month investigation, that Officer Kiel Baitinger-Peterson's use of lethal force against Ruiz, who was armed with a knife during a struggle at Baldwin and Williamson streets on July 22, was legally justified. The decision came after Ozanne and the Dane County Medical Examiner's office reviewed the findings with the Ruiz family and civil rights attorney Ben Crump, who represents them.

Crump said nothing in the videos shown to the family justifies the officer "stepping back, pulling his gun, and firing three shots at point-blank range" after Ruiz had been tased and was on the ground. The medical examiner told the family that without the shot to Ruiz's head, he would have survived, Crump said, calling the killing "unjustifiable, unreasonable, unnecessary, and unconstitutional."

We won't accept this, so we're asking the community to be our judge and jury.

At a press conference at the Center for Black Excellence and Culture, the family appealed to the community to help seek justice. "We won't accept this, so we're asking the community to be our judge and jury," said Adam Ruiz, Corey's brother. A peaceful demonstration marked the Baldwin and Williamson intersection Thursday afternoon and evening, according to In Business Madison.

Police Chief John Patterson expressed sympathy to the family and said the department is launching an internal review of the use of force, the decisions made that day, and adherence to training, procedures and the code of conduct — a review that will include an outside expert. The four officers involved in the attempted arrest remain on administrative leave.

Mayor Satya Rhodes-Conway said in a statement that additional investigations can now be conducted by the Police Department, the Office of the Independent Monitor and the Police and Fire Commission, focused on whether officers followed protocol and whether discipline — up to termination — is appropriate. She noted that under state law only the Police and Fire Commission, not the mayor or council, can discipline an officer. "Corey Ruiz should be alive," she wrote, urging residents to protest peacefully.

Reaction among local officials ran largely sympathetic to the family. State Rep. Francesca Hong, who represents the neighborhood, called the charging decision "disturbing," according to the Cap Times. The Wisconsin Professional Police Association was the lone organization to publicly back the ruling; its executive director, Jim Palmer, said the decision is supported by the evidence and consistent with legal standards for deadly force.

The case returns now to slower channels: the internal review, the oversight agencies and the family's consideration of a civil suit, which the Wisconsin Law Journal reported is under discussion. Madison officers still do not wear body cameras — there is none from the July shooting — though the city has begun funding a camera rollout in next year's budget.

corey ruiz police ismael ozanne willy street city hall

← Back to the front page